Never miss an update


Never miss an update


    NIKE AIR MAX FLAIR Men Size 8.5 Sneakers Silver New in Box Light Pumice GreenGolf Le Fleur size 9.5 Purple Heart Brand NewNew Balance M1300DTO Made in USA in Chambray/White Sizes 6-13 BNIB Free Shipping , Very Nice Nike LeBron XII 12 Black History Month Black/Silver/White!!! 10.5!!!Nike Air More Money Obsidian White AJ2998-400 Size 8 - 12 , 1804 Reebok DMX FUSION TS Men's Sneakers Sports Shoes CN2209 , Air Jordan 1 Ret Hi NYC "23NY" - 715060 002 - 20141803 Reebok Classic Fury Light Men's Sneakers Sports Shoes CM9948AIR JORDAN 2 RETRO CONCORD WHITE BLACK SIZE 10.5 , New Balance M1540SB2 Men's Running Shoe Silver/Blue Synthetic/Mesh Upper , Nike Alabama Crimson Tide Zoom Train Command College Shoes AO4397-061 Size 91803 Reebok Classic Fury Light Men's Sneakers Sports Shoes CM9949 , Nike Air Max 90 EZ Camo Mens AO1745-201 Medium Olive Running Shoes Size 13NIKE BLAZER BLUE SB POETS LIGHTHOUSE SHOES 314070 401 MEN SIZE 11 M1803 Reebok Classic Fury Light Men's Sneakers Sports Shoes CN0024Man's/Woman's Adidas NMD_R1 - B79759 New Listing Various types and styles German OutletsAdidas Originals NMD_CS1 GTX Primeknit in White/Core Black BY9404 Free ShippingMen's/Women's Jordan 5 grape size 11 Rich design cheapest Valuable boutiqueAIR JORDAN 3 III Shoes Size 10 Men Black Flip AthleticNike Women's Flyknit Free RN Flyknit - 831070-503 - Purple Black White Running , AIR JORDAN 1 MID MEN'S BASKETBALL SNEAKER 554724071 , Man/Woman Shoes adidas Quesence Green Men B37851 High grade Lush design Elegant and solemnASICS GEL-Quantum 180 2 MX Men's Phantom/Black/White 8371690 , HOKA ONE ONE BONDI 6 BLACK IRIS/STORM BLUE RUNNING MEN'S SHOES SIZE US 10.5 NEWDS RARE STAN SMITH CONSORTIUM HAILLET HYKE PYTHON , Converse x JW Anderson Chuck 70 bigs Eyelets / 46.5Nike Air SB Eric Koston Max Men Sneaker Sport Shoes Trainers 833446 641 041 SALEGentlemen/Ladies NIKE Kyrie 3 Mens Basketball Shoes Charming design Quality First Official websiteGeox U Kristof A Mens Leather Sneakers / Shoes - Brown ,
    Men's Shoes Saucony Originals Jazz Grey Green Sneaker Fall Winter 2019Dainese Torque D1 In Motorcycle Boots Racing Sport Non-Slip SoleClarks Ladies Medora Frost Elasticated Strap Shoes , AK Anne Klein Womens Collection 10621370 Cutout Compression- Choose SZ/Color. , DANSKO OLIVIA LEOPARD PRINT BRONZE SHIMMER LEATHER LOAFERS SHOES WOMEN'S 38SVEN Original Clogs Womens 36 Or 6 US Sandals Unworn New No Box Green , $225 BCBG MAX AZRIA Women's 'Darien 1' Cutout Peep Toe Pumps, Natural, US 6Cynthia Rowley Women's Surprising Black Fabric Slingback PumpAnne Klein Women's Hangout Synthetic Clog - Choose SZ/ColorDonald Pliner 7 M Embossed Snake Print Patent Leather Peep Toe PumpsAntonio Melani Champagne Clawson Size 7.5 M , $1485 New MANOLO BLAHNIK Rittan JEWELED Silver SNAKE Thong SANDALS SHOES 40.5Asics Gel Diablo Superior Birch Lyte III V HL7U0-0202 Mens 8-12adidas crazy shadow m313 Men's Basketball Shoes Size 8.5 M USNIKE AIR MAX RUN LITE+ MENS SHOES/SNEAKERS/TRAINERS/RUNNERS US SZ 8Nike Men's FS Lite Run 3 Running Sneakers Shoes Red Crimson 807144-002 sz 8.5 , Men's Nike Air Jordan 1 Retro High OG Gatorade Blue Lagoon AJ5997-455 Size 9.5Nike Epic React Flyknit AQ0067-008 Men's Sizes US 7 ~ 15 / New in Box!2009 Nike Dunk High Premium Cassette Playa Edition SZ 14 306968 005 , Nike Metcon 4 MF Mat Fraser HWPO Wod Black Brown SZ US 7.5 ( AR8819-001 )New BATES Men's Tactical Sport COMP TOE Oxford Shoe , NEW KITON SHOES SNEAKERS 100% LEATHER SIZE 10 US 43 KSC51Under Armour 1276375 Men UA Stellar Protect Composite Toe Boot, Black , Converse All Star Chuck Taylor OX 135253C Black Leather Shoes Medium (D, M) MenRARE Damani DADA SUPREME 10.5 Soft LEATHER Slip On VTG Slide Sneakers FALL StyleAdidas Women's NMD_R1 W Shoes Core BlackWhite/Clear Pink B37649 c , Miz Mooz Leather Detailed Sandals - Carey Olive 37 (6.5-7)Chinese Laundry Women's Unnie Wedge Booties Whiskey Brown Size 8.5 M , Womens Open Toe Clear Transparent Over Knee Sandal Boots Block Heel Roman Shoes , Kenneth Cole REACTION Joni Arc Su Ankle Booties 959, Black, 10 US / 41 EU
    Will ETFs cause the next market crash?
    ETF Watch - Jun 29, 2017

    There’s no doubt that the last 2 years has seen the coming of age of ETFs. With what was once an unknown type of investment quickly becoming a $30b industry in Australia ($3 trillion globally). However, as ETFs have moved from the unknown to the flavour of the month, an increasing number of commentators have called on the risks ETF investors face, with some even stating that ETFs will be the source of the next market crash. Today we take a look at some of the claims as to why some believe there are so many risks associated with ETFs.

    Claim 1: ETFS are blindly pushing up stock prices

    Many have written about share markets being at record highs. In an interview with the AFR, Wilson Asset Management chief Geoff Wilson discussed his portfolios’ current high weightings to cash due to concerns of market over-valuations. 

    US based fund manager FPA capital called ETFs “Weapons of Mass Destruction”and stated “The flood of money into passive products is making stock prices move in lockstep and creating markets increasingly divorced from underlying fundamentals”. The argument they make is as ETFs blindly invest in stocks in their chosen index and ignore the underlying fundamentals of these companies. This causes these companies prices to be bid up to prices that do not support their fundamentals (ie a bubble), and eventually history repeats, the bubble bursts and markets crash.

    What do we think?

    ETFs account for around 10% of US stocks’ market value and less than 1% in Australia. In the US at least this is not an immaterial amount. However, the active managers whom ETFs have taken business from generally have mandates which force them to invest a certain percentage in the market. As a result, active managers have always been investing in expensive markets and pushing up prices. Additionally, what is currently called by many analysis as expensive equity markets could also be attributed to global record low interest rates rather than an uptick in passive investing. In saying that, since the last major market crash (the 2008 GFC), the proportion of total assets in ETFs are considerably higher and continual growth of passive investing must be considered as a possible cause of markets becoming expensive.

    Recently we’ve seen Vaneck reweight their huge Junior Gold Miner’s ETF as they approached 20% limits in some of their smaller holdings. This meant selling out of these small gold miners which saw large falls in some of these shares (some of which was blamed on hedge funds looking to capitalise on the opportunity). This is a great example of the influence that ETFs can have, albeit this is at the small end of the market.

    Claim 2: ETFs will sell on mass and compound market falls

    One of the known weaknesses of a managed fund structure is the ability for investors to fairly easily redeem their funds, meaning at times of market falls, when a fund manager may find the best investment opportunities, the investors in the fund are panicking and redeeming their investments, meaning the fund manager becomes a forced seller rather than a buyer. This was one of the reasons Forager decided to turn their Australian Share Fund (FOR) into a Listed Investment Trust, where the pool of capital for them to invest was guaranteed.

    The one thing stopping simple redemption of managed funds during market crashes is another one of its weaknesses, which is managed funds are not simple to trade, and require the investor to apply to the fund to redeem units. This can involve filling out paper forms, and an apathetic investor may simply not be bothered.

    What do we think?

    One of the greatest advantages of ETFs is also one of its weaknesses when it comes to the above, with ETFs able to be traded on the ASX, a panicked investor simply has to log into their online brokerage account and hit the sell button. If a buyer does not exist on the other side of the trade, the ETF issuer is forced to then sell the underlying holdings which could very well begin a contagion effect.

    However, we come back to the size of the ETF market, at around 1% of the Australian market and 10% of the US market. Investors selling underlying stocks that they own through their broker will have the exact same impact as the reasonably small proportion of ETFs. We believe the actual impact of this event would be not materially higher than what currently exists.

    Claim 3: ETFS with low liquidity will be hard to sell if markets fall

    Peter Switzer recently spoke about a client who had received advice that an ETF with low liquidity would be difficult to sell if markets fall. The argument being that without a liquid market the seller would be unable to find a buyer on the other side of the trade and would need to sell at a significant discount.

    What do we think?

    One of the somewhat unknown components of ETFs is the role of the market maker. Essentially the market maker’s role is to provide liquidity to an ETF, so that if there is not an existing ETF unit on the other side of an ETF trade, the market maker must create an ETF unit for a buyer, or absorb an ETF unit for a seller. It is then the ETF issuer's role to buy or sell the underlying assets that the ETF holds. This means that regardless of an ETF’s liquidity, a market maker will always exist to buy an ETF off an investor even if the markets in free fall.

    However, there is a caveat to the above. Market makers make a profit by charging a spread between the buy price and the sell price of an ETF. The spread becomes the market maker’s profit margin. In a free falling market it may be difficult for the market maker to price the underlying investments forcing them to create a huge spread between the buy and sell price to protect their margins. This was seen in the 2015 Dow Jones ‘Flash Crash’, where some ETFs dropped 30% when the market makers were unable to price the underlying securities.


    Finally, an ETF is only ever as liquid as its underlying holdings. ETFs which invest in illiquid investments may have great liquidity, but if the underlying investments do not, this will likely be reflected in falls in both the underlying holdings and the ETF during market falls. This may be more likely to play out at the small cap end of the sharemarket and within unlisted asset classes.

    Claim 4: ‘Exotic’ ETFs are higher risk

    In a recent RBA publication, economist Michelle Cunningham discussed the risks faced with some of the more exotic ETFs, those that are classed as ‘synthetic’ ETFs, meaning the ETF issuer does not hold the underlying investments, rather they rely on a counterparty to pay the return. These ETFs are generally referred to as ‘Synthetic’ or ‘Hedge fund’ in their title. Cunningham raised the risk that the counterparty may default on their obligation, so an additional level of risk exists for the investor.

    What do we think?

    We agree with Cunningham’s analysis, an additional level of risk certainly exists with these ETF structures, however in many cases this is the only way to access to investment strategy that the ETF provides. Nevertheless, investors should be aware of the additional risks that exist.


    There’s plenty of arguments in both camps about ETFs role in future market crashes. There’s no doubt the world has moved into uncharted territory with the rise of passive investing & ETFs in particular. We do believe, however, that some of the risks are overblow. Nevertheless, investors should be aware of these risks in order to make informed investing decisions. What do you think?


    Previous Article

    2017 Financial Year ETF and LIC Performance Table

    Next Article

    New Fixed Interest ETFs expand options for investors

    Leave a Reply
    Find a Fund
    Athletic Shoes